Having an elaborate skincare routine is a fantastic habit as it keeps your face plump and moisturized.
However, without proper sun protection, all that hard work can go to waste. That’s when I started my research and found many skincare enthusiasts asking who would win in a Sun Bum vs Banana Boat sunscreen competition.
After some digging around and a little experimenting, I’m ready to share my thoughts on how these two stack up against each other!
Spoiler alert: they both have their strengths, but cater to slightly different needs and preferences.
This post contains affiliate links.
Sun Bum: A Company’s Story
When I used Sun Bum, all I could think of was warm sand, salty air, and the kind of carefree vibe that makes you want to call in sick and hit the waves!
Back in 2010, Sun Bum’s founders set out on one simple mission: to create sun care products to protect their families and friends.
What made Sun Bum different for me wasn’t just their laid-back vibe or chic packaging; it was their eco-conscious approach.
Their products are reef-safe, cruelty-free, and designed with sustainability in mind.
Knowing I didn’t have to worry about those beautiful sea creatures because of my sunscreen made the waves more inviting!
Banana Boat: Walking Down Memory Lane
Unlike Sun Bum, Banana Boat goes all the way back to the 1970s! The company started on the shores of Miami Beach, where a lifeguard saw a gap in the market.
All the available options were either too greasy, medicinal, or both, which didn’t exactly scream “fun on the beach!”
So, he set out to change that by creating a lighter, non-greasy formula packaged in a bright, colorful tube.
What made Banana Boat stand out for me is its focus on ensuring everyone is protected in whichever way they prefer.
With sprays, sticks, and lotions tailored to kids, athletes, and everyone in between, there’s a product for almost every adventure under the sun!
Moreover, the company’s products are free from oxybenzone and octinoxate.
This means you can feel guilt-free about protecting your skin as you won’t compromise on safety or environmental responsibility!
Product Showdown
Now that you know more about each company, it’s time to see how two of their main products compare!
Sun Bum Original SPF 30 Sunscreen Lotion
With a subtle coconut scent and thick, creamy consistency, the Sun Bum Original SPF30 lotion gives me beach flashbacks even when applying it before work!
The formula is water-resistant for up to 80 minutes and blends perfectly without leaving a white cast.
While it’s not the thinnest sunscreen out there, the thicker texture does give a reassuring feeling, especially if you want full coverage.
Pros
- Subtle coconut fragrance
- Water-resistant
- Non-greasy
- Octinoxate- and oxybenzone-free
- Reef-safe formula
Cons
- The thicker consistency might not suit everybody
- Some users have reported breakouts. I’d advise a small patch test first.
Banana Boat Protection + Vitamins Moisturizing Sunscreen Lotion SPF 30
In my opinion, Banana Boat takes a more holistic approach to sun protection.
The lotion’s formula is packed with skin-adoring ingredients like vitamin C and niacinamide, which not only protect against UV rays but also brighten skin, reduce discoloration, and lock in hydration for up to 12 hours.
It’s also lightweight, which helps the skin absorb it quickly. My only remark on this lotion was its citrusy smell, which I personally wasn’t a huge fan of.
Pros
- Water-resistant for up to 80 minutes
- Has vitamin C and niacinamide for extra skin benefits
- Lightweight and fast-absorbing
- Octinoxate- and oxybenzone-free
- Awarded the Skin Cancer Foundation Seal for Daily Use
Cons
- The citrus scent might feel overpowering to sensitive noses
The Verdict
For me, the Banana Boat SPF 30 protection lotion wins the sun protection competition! Its lightweight formula makes it easy to reach for it whenever I step outside the house.
Also, my experience with niacinamide made it a no-brainer for me as it truly helps with discoloration and moisture.
However, does this mean that Sun Bum’s lotion was bad? Absolutely not! It’s perfect for days spent by the ocean, but not the best when it comes to daily use.
Wrapping Up
So, who won the Sun Bum vs. Banana Boat competition for you?
While Banana Boat’s lightweight structure, vitamin C, and niacinamide won my heart, Sun Bum’s eco-conscious approach and subtle coconut scent made it hard to resist!
Ultimately, it comes down to what you value most in your sunscreen. Banana Boat’s lotion might be the perfect fit if you want a multitasking sunscreen that hydrates, brightens, and feels light.
On the other hand, if you’re drawn to sunscreen with a beachy vibe, eco-friendly ingredients, and a thick, moisturizing formula, Sun Bum Original lotion is a good pick!
Drop a comment below with your favorite sunscreen!