When I hear the word mascara, the first color that pops to mind is black. It’s an absolute classic, with timeless appeal and bold definition. Generally, black mascara has long been the standard for creating eye-catching lashes.
That said, you might not know that you can create an equally attractive look using a mascara color like brown. With a more neutral approach, brown mascara can be an alternative that complements various styles.
Keep reading to learn more about the differences between brown vs black mascara.
This post contains affiliate links.
Brown vs. Black Mascara: Choosing Criteria
Deciding between brown and black mascara depends on many factors. Aside from your personal preferences and style, here’s what you should consider:
1. Skin Tone and Hair Color
Black mascara is ideal for individuals with medium to dark skin tones and darker hair colors. It complements their natural beauty and gives the eyes a striking definition.
As for brown mascara shades, they work better for people with fairer skin and light hair colors. For blondes or redheads, brown lashes enhance their looks without appearing too contradictory to their other features.
2. Eye Color
Both brown and black mascaras can be flattering on different eye colors, creating gorgeous effects.
- Hazel and Brown Eyes: While the brown mascara enhances their warmth, black mascara adds drama, making them stand out.
- Green Eyes: Brown mascara creates a soft look without overpowering the green color. On the other hand, black mascara contrasts with green eyes and makes them pop.
- Blue Eyes: Brown mascara on blue eyes maintains a natural, everyday appearance. Yet, black mascara can make the eyes appear more vivid.
3. Occasion
For daytime, work environments, or no-makeup makeup looks, brown mascara is a perfect choice. It gives your eyes a well-defined look without being too dramatic.
On the contrary, black mascara suits evening looks and nighttime occasions much better. It adds more glamor and sophistication, which makes your eyes stand out.
4. Desired Look
If you’re aiming for a delicate look with a soft lash definition, brown mascara is what you need. This works best in situations where an understated appearance is preferable.
As for black mascara, it must be your choice for more glamorous looks where you want to leave a lasting impression. It adds more volume and makes you look more intense.
Top Recommendations for Mascaras Available in Brown and Black
Picking the right mascara is just as essential as deciding the right color. Such an addition can have a huge impact on your final makeup look.
Here are three of my favorite mascaras on the market:
1. Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky-High Washable Mascara: This mascara exceeds all expectations with a unique brush that lengthens your lashes. Being buildable also allows for great control over your desired volume.
2. e.l.f. Lash ‘N Roll Mascara: e.l.f. Lash ‘N Roll: Another strong contender for both black and brown mascaras. Besides being highly affordable, this mascara provides an outstanding curling effect and a non-clumpy finish.
3. Yves Saint Laurent Lash Clash Extreme Volume Mascara: This mascara is more high-end, but the volume and thickness it provides are exceptional.
Do you have a preference between brown vs black mascara, or any favorite products? Let me know in the comments below!
For more eye makeup inspiration: